Kaddu (Sweet and Sour Butternut Squash) Recipe (2024)

I thought this was a really good recipe! Sweet, sour, spicy. Yum! I used mustard seeds instead of fenugreek. I ended up having to cook the squash about 8-10 extra minutes. And did 1/4 tsp of regular chili powder and 1/4 of cayenne. I like spicy but think it would have been too spicy with a full 1/2 tsp cayenne. Next time I think I’d add a little crunch with either some chopped roasted peanuts or fried shallots!

This turned out amazing! The flavor was incredible! Only substitutions were using acorn squash instead of butternut, and I used 1 can diced tomatoes instead of fresh, since the ones at the store were looking a little sad. I am going to make this again and again!

This is an excellent recipe. If you're preparing this for Navarati, skip the onions and tumeric, which are not allowed during the fast. You can also include green chiles, mustard seeds, cumin seeds as well as tamarind, which are all allowed.

This was delicious, I’ll be making it many more times. I cooked the squash a while longer, ~45 min on medium low till it was soft and partially broken down and saucy. Used canned tomatoes, no other changes. Really delicious, the flavors are bright and multilayered, balanced, substantial but not heavy - beautiful.

I agree this is a delicious dish. I didn’t find fenugreek seeds, so I used 1/2 tsp ground fenugreek that I added with the turmeric. @Kyra, I used 1/2 tsp cayenne as recipe calls for - not too spicy. I used local, organic yellow cherry tomatoes from the farmers market, and maple syrup in place of the brown sugar. Don’t leave off the cilantro. It definitely adds something to provide the full umami flavor. The 25 min. is just cooking time. W/ peeling, chopping, etc, this took a good hour to make.

Just gorgeous! Rarely do I have everything for a recipe on-hand, but I did today. Taking the convenience route with pre-cut organic squash and diced tomatoes, it came together fairly quickly. The squash cubes were much larger than the recipe specified, so the cooking time was longer, and I stirred everything a few times to be sure the squash was cooked. PS: if you grind several peeled ginger roots in a mini-processor and freeze it in 1 tablespoon clumps, you can do recipes like this in a flash.

My Mom makes this every year for Diwali. She used pumpkin which is a nice way to deal with non-carved pumpkins you may have gotten for Halloween. She cuts them into large chunks, leaving the peal on. No onions, or tomato, but adds in green chilis and powdered coriander. So tasty!

This was a fantastic "yellow" dish to replace our tired sweet potatoes with marshmallows for the Thanksgiving feast. I prepped the squash and onions the day before which made cooking a breeze and used canned diced tomatoes (15 oz) instead of the roma tomatoes. I cooked it down to soften it (30 min) but left the squash with some firmness. Even more delicious the next day as a breakfast side with eggs!

Delightful mix of sweet, sour and spice. To add protein, added drained can of chickpeas and fried in oil before adding fenugreek seeds. Used a little less than Tablespoon of brown sugar and subbed plum tomatoes and grape tomatoes for Roma. Came together quite easily in wok. Served over quinoa. Definitely will make again and again.

I make stovetop squash and sweet potato dishes all the time -- but here's a tip, chop them up and throw the chunks in a steamer basket for five-ten minutes before adding to the saute pan. This softens them up and makes them more amenable to mixing with the other ingredients. I find it hard to believe you can cook raw squash this way in only 10 mins!

Allow time for the prep; I wrestled with the squash for a while! Excellent flavours, even though I had to sub mustard seeds. No coriander so topped with parsley and green onion. Served up with toasted naan, mango chutney and a few nuts. Happy Thanksgiving to American cooks from up in the North!

I found that leftovers were great in salads. I used baby spinach, cubed avocado, and goat cheese, with olive oil and Japanese rice vinegar, and a glop (however much you want) of the squash. Interesting flavors - I may make the recipe in the future just to have On hand for salads.

Cooked exactly as directed but in an Instant Pot. 30 minutes and it was perfect and delicious.

A different way to serve butternut squash. The mix of spices come together nicely. However there is no way butternut squash will soften in 15 minutes. It took me closer to 40 minutes.

Adapted a bit based on what I had on hand. Used Panch Puron Indian spice mix, 14 Oz can of fire roasted tomatoes, drained. Smallish squash so reduced everything accordingly. Very adaptable recipe. Loved it. Will keep in rotation.

Made this last night with an array of other Indian inspired dishes. My kids and I loved it...btw, kids are 29 (haha).

Didn't have fenugreek so substituted maple syrup and omitted the the brown sugar as well.Also, substituted canned tomatoes without the juice for the fresh tomatoes. Also substituted Korean gochugaru for the red pepper flakes.

Made this for Thanksgiving as suggested in the video. Easy, interesting, and delicious! Flavors I haven't experienced for a long time. Probably need to find more uses for my fenugreek and asafetida.

The video shows that she does not peel the squash at all!

Outstanding depth and complexity of flavor and very easy to make. 1/2" cubes of squash easily cooked in the time suggested. Used canned tomatoes; otherwise made no alterations. (I did use asafetida, which is always good.) Served with quick flatbreads; would also be good with rice.

I’m afraid this one was a rare dud for me. I was pretty faithful to the recipe. I just didn’t love the flavor and texture. If I were to try to tweak this recipe (I do love fenugreek), I might roast the squash cubes ahead of assembling the curry. I think a little caramelization might help.

Delicious!

I only had two small honey nut squash, so I added in chard, which worked really well. I loved this.

I love this recipe - one of my all time favorite ways to prepare squash. Similar to others I sometimes have to cook the squash a bit longer, and often use canned diced tomatoes especially during the winter.

Amazing! Put a fried egg on top

In the video for this recipe, the author seems to cut and cook the squash unpeeled.

This was easy to make and delicious but with 1/2 tap of cayenne ours was tongue tingling hot. And we like spicy. I would use less next time but some yogurt mixed with lime juice, salt and pepper tamed the heat.

Made this for Thanksgiving. Excellent, and my guests liked it too.

Loved it. I could only find pumpkin but it was delicious. Honestly I could have gone even spicier when I tasted it so I served with some green pepper flakes.

This is SO good. And pretty for company. I added chopped roasted peanuts as another post suggested and think the taste and crunch are essential. Also followed another post by steaming squash in advance for 10 mins. Made the rest of the cooking go quickly.